The plural of anecdote is not data — even when it’s ‘crowdsourced’
Tuesday, 11 March 2008, 18:05
I really like what the Times does online, but I must say that Roy Greenslade’s analysis of today’s Times splash is right on the money.
It doesn’t take university-level stats to know that self-selecting samples cannot be extrapolated to populations. An online vote touted as “a new kind of interactive poll” is no different than the sort of phone-in vote that papers have run for years.
It’s a very clever way of creating a very big collection of anecdotes, but to call it a “poll”, interactive or not, is misleading.
My favourite bit (in the printed editon) was this: “The poll, which attracted 2,476 responses, is novel because it reflects not just hard statistical data, but people’s observations and anxieties about the state of the economy”.
Eh? “Hard statistical data”? Where? Methinks the “just” was superfluous.
Further down (in a tiny boxout at the foot of the jump on page 4) communities editor Tom Whitwell provides the disclaimer that should have been right up in paragraph two — the story “does not have the statistical rigour of an opinion poll”.
The Times isn’t the first newspaper to report its online votes as if they were some sort of survey, of course. But to sacrifice the intellectual rigour of a story for the sake of fostering online “community” or experimenting with “crowdsourcing” is a very strange set of journalistic priorities indeed.
I wonder how many letters will flood in tomorrow from the Royal Statistical Society and various OxBridge dons.
Friday, 7 March 2008, 18:09
Comments
"Google Analytics Industry Benchmarking will let users opt-in to share and have access to aggregate traffic info for websites in their industry vertical and at other points in their supply chain."
Tuesday, 22 January 2008, 22:43
Comments
"Now, says Sifry, Technorati indexes 112 million blogs, with 120 thousand new ones appearing each day. And that’s not including spam blogs [which now] account for—get this—well over 99% of all the pings and updates pouring into Technorati’s server
Monday, 17 December 2007, 00:21
Comments
"In what is believed to be the first statistical analysis of player performance for those named in the 409-page report, the Journal Sentinel … found …"
Monday, 26 November 2007, 17:04
Comments
Tim O’Reilly promotes mathematical literacy with a discussion of trends in major websites’ traffic growth.
Thursday, 8 November 2007, 17:34
Comments
"the Royal Statistical Society is running a FREE workshop for journalists to help them get more out of the statistics in the public domain"
Wednesday, 22 August 2007, 09:51
Comments
"Many of our clients" the company says candidly, "use OnePoll to trigger high impact media coverage". "Our team of national news journalists and PR experts know what the media will use".
Wednesday, 20 June 2007, 15:23
Comments
"YouTube looks set to overtake BBC.co.uk in share of UK visits within a matter of weeks."
Tuesday, 8 May 2007, 18:21
Comments
Twitter is growing a tad faster than Blogger did in its first 253 days. Jason Kottke looks at why this might be the case.
Friday, 20 April 2007, 12:38
Comments
Seamus McCauley: "The idea of a participative, read/write web2.0 is a myth - that most people simply aren’t contributing, just consuming."
Friday, 13 April 2007, 00:14
Comments
Somehow missed this: the top US newspaper sites, based on Nielson/Netratings data. NY Times is top with a unique audience of 12,960,000 users and 455,527,000 pvs.in February.
