Note to journalism schools: give us new heroes

Tuesday, 16 January 2007, 18:44

Update: This post has been sitting in my drafts since I wrote it two nights ago. I wasn’t quite happy with it, but now that Kevin Anderson has pre-empted me with almost the same title, I’d better hit “publish”.

Responding to my rant about journalism students who want nothing to do with the multimedia future of their trade, Adrian Monck (who is head of my j-school alma mater) wrote:

The things that inspire you to undertake a career are usually drawn from your past. Add to that the competitive pressures, and the financial commitment required and you can see why some students might wish to enter an industry that looks like the one they wanted to join when they were growing up.

This is a fair point.

One of the reasons so many students appear to aspire to old-school journalism jobs must be that the only image of journalism they ever receive through popular culture is hopelessly dated. I’ll happily admit that when I was 16 years old, I aspired to a career that looked a bit like All the President’s Men, albeit with desktop publishing. This was 1995 — more than 20 years after Watergate.

(I must have snapped out of it quickly, because I built my high school newspaper’s first web site a year later.)
Perhaps the first thing every journalism course needs to do — on day one of each new intake — is to provide some examples of impressive current careers, so that students can aspire to be the pioneering journalists of their own generation rather than the ideal-types of their lecturers’.

Teach some new heroes: You know, the people out there doing impressive stuff with new technologies right now. The war reporters traveling the world doing solo multimedia reporting; the investigative reporters using sophisticated software to take on the CIA, the laid-off print hacks going it alone to build successful online publications, the people bringing software development skills into journalism.

Need a recent journalism film to dislodge Dustin Hoffman and Robert Redford? Try Shattered Glass — a story where the fraudulent titular hack is found out by an online journalist. The hero there is Adam Penenberg, then of Forbes.com. A key part of the story is Penenberg’s scepticism about the phoney website the technologically-unsophisticated Glass had set up to disguise his made-up stories for the New Republic, er, magazine.

Then on day two, you can start preparing them for strange new jobs like “mojo”, “database editor”, “podcast editor” or “community editor”.

Update: Over at Strange Attractor, Adrian Monck suggests adding an exemplary journalism student to the list of new media role models: Dave Cohn, a student at Columbia University and editor of NewAssignment.net, is certainly a good example to point out. He has a great piece in the Columbia Journalism Review today about his use of Digg.

Who else should be added to the list?

Entry Filed under: Journalism, Journalism Education

20 Comments Add some more of your own

1. Dave Lee | 17 January 2007 at 0006

Hi Martin,

This is the first post of yours that I have read, and it’s prompted me to write an absolute essay on the subject on my own blog today.

I think you have hit the nail on the head. I’m a journalism student at Lincoln University, and all formats of journalism are taught as completely seperate entities. Which as you rightly point out, is dangerously archaic.
2. Notes from a Teacher: Mar&hellip | 17 January 2007 at 0240

[...] Note to journalism schools: give us new heroes. Martin Stabe with a second post on the need to reimagine journalism education in light of new realities to give students a realistic look at what media is becoming — whether they want it or not. [...]
3. Paul Bradshaw | 17 January 2007 at 1238

An inspiring post that I’ll certainly be recommending to my students, and the point about careers early on is also one I’ll be recommending we adopt. Last year we introduced a ‘Production Event’ in year one where journalism students work as a news agency - producing copy for print, TV, radio and online during a ‘themed’ week (like the BBC’s Africa week, for instance). It’s a great way to demonstrate the range of forms you may be asked to produce material for, gets students working with specialists in a range of media - and they love it!
4. Online Journalism Blog&hellip | 17 January 2007 at 1255

Note to journalism schools: give us new heroes
5. Martin Stabe » One &hellip | 17 January 2007 at 1338

[...] This nicely sums up both the posts I wrote yesterday. Online journalism is being shaped by entrepreneurial journalists like Rick, who have recognised that their fate is no longer inextricably tied up with the fate of big print publishing companies. The Internet is disrupting publishing, not journalism. Journalism students should be paying close attention to journalists like Rick. [...]
6. Andy Dickinson.net »&hellip | 17 January 2007 at 1441

[...] The journalism education debate moves on a pace. Martin Stabe and Andrew Grant Adamson, Kevin Anderson amongst others are coming up with some good stuff. It all boils down to the same message: Journalism students need heroes. [...]
7. Innovation in College Med&hellip | 17 January 2007 at 1526

[...] There’s lots of interesting discussion going on about the state of journalism education, much of it crossing the Atlantic. Read these posts from Andy Dickinson, Martin Stabe, Kevin Anderson, and Andrew Grant-Adamson in the UK, practioners and academics all. Then read this from Dave Lee, a student in the UK. In the U.S., of course, there’s Mindy McAdams’ post from last week that started this ball rolling. Then there’s Bob Stepno. And don’t miss Ryan Sholin’s young gun words of wisdom. Or Matt Waite. Or Danny Sanchez. I’d like to see some thoughts from U.S. journalism students who write blogs. I know they’re out there. Link in, folks. This is your future we’re talking about here. Lots to read there. Lots to think about. But the very fact that there are so many people talking about these issues and sharing ideas with each other increases the possibility that we’ll all benefit. It’s that “wisdom of crowds” thing again. This whole conversation illustrates something Howard Owens mentioned in his interview with me. There’s a social nature to the World Wide Web that you have to be a part of to understand. And journalists need to increase their understanding. Share and Enjoy:These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages. [...]
8. Innovation in College Med&hellip | 17 January 2007 at 1548

[...] Martin Stabe asks for journalism schools to give journalism students new heroes to replace the old standbys of Woodward and Bernstein. [...]
9. Bryan Murley | 17 January 2007 at 1700

David Cohn will be speaking at our CMA session in New York this March. Good thing we booked him before he became a “hero.”
10. SacredFacts&hellip | 17 January 2007 at 1824

Martin Stabe » Note to journalism schools: give us new heroes
11. David Cohn | 17 January 2007 at 2330

Martin — thanks for your confidence and compliment.

This entire thread of links and comments is right on the noise — journalism students need new heros.

Your example of Adam Penenberg is perfect. He was a hero to me, especially because he had a column at Wired News when I was an intern there.

I think I got lucky in the draw — I was intrigued by journalism, the idea of engaging in the national conversation, but I am also, for lack of a better word — a geek.

In addition to Woodward, Bernstein and other journalists, I look up to Craig Newmark, Jimmy Wales and other geek idols. They inspire me to go beyond research, reporting etc (all the irreplaceable fundamentals) to question the modes, mediums and practices of journalism.
12. David Cohn | 18 January 2007 at 0451

Don’t you hate when you make a comment, read it over and realize you made a word slip. I meant “this entire thread of links and comments is right on the nose.”

Eh… it happens…and a little humility never hurt.
13. SOJo: Student of Online J&hellip | 18 January 2007 at 0600

Where is Raed ? Kevin Sites in the Hot Zone: Conflict Journalist & Video News Steve Yelvington Seth M. Gitner - Multimedia Journalist RConversation Richard Koci Hernandez Adrian Holovaty Rob Curley Martin Stabe Placeblogger Coconut Grove Grapevine MultiZ: Advance Multi Search Engine
14. Invisible Inkling »&hellip | 18 January 2007 at 0623

[...] Lee read Martin Stabe’s follow-up to “The conservatism of journalism students” and put out a call for more heroes in journalism. [...]
15. Benjie Boy | 20 January 2007 at 0156

DC for chaplan
16. Howie Good | 21 February 2007 at 0253

I’m a journalism prof in the U.S. One of my teaching and research areas is ethics. I’ve asked other journalism profs via posts on a couple of Web sites to nominate journalists, living or dead, to put before our students as moral exemplars. I also asked them to briefly explain why they think these journalists qualify. So far . . . nothing. Does that speak to the state of journalism ethics or the state of journalism education or both? And while we’re at it, who do you think belongs on any such list?
17. Howie Good | 21 February 2007 at 0437

hello?
18. NewAssignment.Net | an ex&hellip | 1 March 2007 at 1358

I’ve come across plenty of cries about how journalism schools need to re-think what they teach in order to better incorporate new media skills. The one that hit it home for me was reading advice from Rob Curley posted at the College Media Innovation blog
19. DigiDave&hellip | 28 August 2007 at 0819

Creating a community atmosphere requires the right tools (software) as well as the right tone. Communities don’t spring up overnight. They need to be cared for, managed, and constantly groomed. It is a skill. I’ve also heard calls for newjournalismheroes. So, just for fun, I’ve decided to create my own Community Dream Team — people who I look up to as heroes in community building. I’ve cast a wide net. I might revisit this one day and cast a smaller net, limiting it to journalims heroes. But I
20. NewAssignment.Net | an ex&hellip | 4 September 2007 at 1625

Creating a community atmosphere requires the right tools (software) as well as the right tone. Communities don’t spring up overnight. They need to be cared for, managed, and constantly groomed. It is a skill. I’ve also heard calls for newjournalismheroes.So, just for fun, I’ve decided to create my own Community Dream Team — people who I look up to as heroes in community building. I’ve cast a wide net. I might revisit this one day and cast a smaller net, limiting it to journalim heroes. But

Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Trackback this post | Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed